• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Jane Binnion

  • Home
  • Social media training
  • Ethical sales training
  • Women in business
  • Blog
  • 0 items£0.00
Home > Binnion Blogs > Business education > Do learning institutions have a responsibility to be ethical role models?

June 4, 2016

Do learning institutions have a responsibility to be ethical role models?

Being dyspraxic, a sociology graduate and having been round the block a few times, I take pride in the fact that I have pretty good emotional intelligence and am wired to look at things logically.

BUT every now and then something smacks me around the head, makes me wonder if I slipped into a parallel universe in my sleep and I lose my equilibrium for a while (thank goodness Facebook also exists in this parallel universe and my Facebook friends come on the journey with me).

This week was one of those times. As a columnist for the Lancaster Guardian I buy it each week to check out  the local news. My friend Jack Knight does the weekly cartoon which is always cryptic  and sends me off in search of the related news item, but this one (above) baffled me.  Then I was drawn to this story…

Uni’s £1m green deal gets mixed reaction

and believe me the article took a twist that I was really not expecting.

The headline had me thinking the pro-fracking lobby were having a mardy, so when I read that Lancaster University invests in the tobacco industry my brain blew a fuse.  Being a logical person I like to research and look at what’s behind things, but try as I might I could not figure out what crucial piece of information I was missing here.

To be totally honest my first  thoughts were that the students were objecting to the sale of ciggies on campus.

On what grounds, other than pure profit, would anyone invest in the tobacco industry today? (please do tell me if I’m missing something) . I’ve had my fair share of  relatives and friends  die of lung cancer or develop other smoking related illnesses.  Of course in the early  days no-one knew it was dangerous went the argument. Then it was known but hidden  of course as these things tend to be, but now we are 100% clear  that smoking is crazy- right? ( I wont even go into the international issues, such as  the falling market in the rich world leading to aggressive marketing in the poor world, the issue of food crops v cash crops etc etc, or even the cost of smoking related health issues for our poor old NHS).

So how does a prestigious university like Lancaster, that has a cancer research department by-the-way, justify it? Well they’re quoted as saying they invest  “ a small proportion “ of their £5.3m endowment onto fossil fuel, tobacco and the arms trade.

Now I’m not meaning to single out Lancaster Uni here, I’m not so naive as to think it’s only them. But I do think they have a responsibility to be a role model to the young minds we hand over to them, and my 17 year old daughter was as shocked as me that an  establishment that is all about education doesn’t behave better than that.

What gave my equilibrium a sharp wobble is that  I teach ethical sales, and this is the wet kipper to the chops that reminds me that whilst small and innovative organisations are seeking to be ethical, the big boys;

a) just don’t give a poop

and

b) think that spreading their investment balances it out.

How? We make profit from cancer + we also invest in cancer research = we are good?

So I am left sitting with ‘what has to happen to Really shift people to think beyond making a quick buck?’

If educational establishments, supposedly filled to the rafters with some of the world’s the best minds,  don’t do joined up thinking who will?

I know a part of my wobble is that we are neighbours. I deliver training there, I’ve sat in numerous  lectures there  about ethical trade and  sustainability. I had a lovely afternoon there just last week drinking coffee and eating cake with MA students who want to study my business growth group.   Next will I find out that 82 year old May up the road who dog sits is really a dog- napper selling our beloved pets for medical experiments?

I don’t want to believe it, although all the evidence is there. So I have to notice why I didn’t notice, why I didn’t want to notice?

And who else knows? Does our local cancer charity know? Do the people that donate to their cancer research programme know?  Why don’t we know?  Have we just stopped looking?

The genius is that it’s all  there for us to see, they are hiding in plain sight. It’s all such a complex web that we don’t know where to start because what else might we find?  And what decisions will we have to make then?

These big boys know that we don’t want to look too closely. And I am as guilty as the next person.  Sure I bank with the Co-op,  took my mortgage out with an ethical investor and I buy fair trade, but what about everything else? My local government pension? My petrol? Where do we start?!

Well in truth we have started, lots of changes are being made, it’s slow and we have a long way to go but I know we are getting there.

More and more people are choosing ethical over greed, asking questions about supply chains and a company’s back story and I have every faith that Lancaster Uni will get there too. We will get there one customer at a time, one supplier at a time, one decision at a time. It feels like  baby steps but  we keep moving in the right direction .

Apparently twenty one UK universities have now made fossil free commitments including Oxford University, Glasgow University and the University of Warwick. That’s a step in the right direction and it will force others will follow. And today Greenpeace UK announced that  General Mills, makers of Betty Crocker cake mixes, have agreed to stop buying from palm oil giant IOI, another  step towards protecting Indonesia’s rain forests.

And lucky for us, our young people are smart,  tenacious and not at all  impressed with the mess we made!

You can find out more about the fabulous Jack Knight here

Filed Under: Business education Tagged With: The ethical business

Jane Binnion is an ethical business trainer based in Lancashire UK. To contact Jane, email jane@janebinnion.com

Previous Post: « Why customers don’t need to know your hourly rate – a confession
Next Post: Can women have it all? – Dealing with overwhelm »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Caroline Thompson says

    7th June 2016 at 10:10 pm

    Wow! Definitely hiding in plain sight – you got that one right.

    It is surprising what goes on that so many of us don’t have a clue about. Nestle is the biggie in our industry as they are so tenacious and aggressive in their marketing of formula milk but so many people are completely unaware.

    Keep shouting about the ones you find Jane – every little bit adds up!

    • Jane says

      8th June 2016 at 9:01 pm

      Thank you Caroline. Indeed Nestle have been behaving badly for a long time and have now just found out they are using slave labour in Thailand. But at least we are finding out about these things more now.

Primary Sidebar

Recent posts

  • Are your customer care systems letting your social media team down?
  • We just keep on growing – Growing Club 4 and The Sowing Club
  • Seven things women in business can learn from Cat Smith’s election campaign
  • We never make the same mistake twice…
  • A week of not being Wonder Woman

Post categories

Get in touch

The best way to get hold of me is to pick up the phone, I’m always happy to chat.

01524 752723
07521 314926

If I’m not there, leave a message and I’ll get back to you as soon as I can.

Alternatively, you may find me on Twitter @janebinnion or you can send me a message using this form

    Footer

    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter

    Recent blog posts

    • Are your customer care systems letting your social media team down?
    • We just keep on growing – Growing Club 4 and The Sowing Club
    • Seven things women in business can learn from Cat Smith’s election campaign
    • We never make the same mistake twice…
    • A week of not being Wonder Woman

    Newsletter

    Legal & technical

    • Privacy Policy
    • Cookie Policy

    Trading name of Ethical Business Training Limited.
    Registered in England and Wales No: 9466041
    45 Meadow Park, Galgate, LA20NH.
    Director Jane Binnion

    © 2010–2022 · Site by Powerhut · Built on the Genesis Framework